Featured blog image

With Election Day behind us, one of the big questions is whether buyers who put their searches on hold will start returning to the market. We’ve seen a welcome improvement in contract activity since September, but the latest numbers suggest that momentum remains somewhat uneven as we approach Thanksgiving.

Historically, the holiday slowdown has had a more consistent impact on NYC real estate than the election calendar. That said, consequential elections can sometimes provide buyers with the clarity or confidence they’ve been waiting for. Whether that translates into additional contracts, and how quickly, remains to be seen.

Manhattan: Less Inventory, Mixed Demand

Manhattan active inventory declined 1.7% to 5,897 listings, down 9.7% from last year. New listings also fell to 221, another indication that the fall listing season is winding down and buyers shouldn’t expect a significant wave of new inventory before spring.

Blog image

Courtesy of UrbanDigs.com

On the demand side, there’s been some encouraging improvement. The 30-day contract pace reached 935, up considerably from 668 in mid-October, although still 8.2% below last year.

Blog image

Courtesy of UrbanDigs.com

Weekly signed contracts, however, fell nearly 20% to 189. One week doesn’t make a trend, particularly this time of year, but it does raise the question of whether the recent pickup in buyer activity can hold up as we head into the holidays.

Another interesting number is that 48% of Manhattan’s active listings have been on the market for more than 90 days. That’s a significant share, especially considering how tight overall inventory remains. It reinforces something we’ve been seeing for a while now: buyers are active, but they’re selective. Well-priced, well-presented properties are finding buyers, while anything that misses on price, condition, or layout can still sit.

Brooklyn: More Choices, Selective Buyers

Brooklyn is telling a somewhat different story. Active inventory stands at 3,725 listings, up 3.4% year-over-year, giving buyers more options than they had at this point last year.

Blog image

Courtesy of UrbanDigs.com

Demand is showing some improvement, with the 30-day contract pace rising 2.3% to 537, though it remains 9.9% below last year. Weekly contracts declined 5.7% to 115, nearly 20% below last year’s pace.

Blog image

Courtesy of UrbanDigs.com

What’s interesting is that some of the higher-priced properties that are finding buyers are actually moving relatively quickly. Among pending contracts, properties above $2M have a median of just 43 days on market, compared with 64 days for properties below $1M.

That tells us the market isn’t necessarily lacking buyers across the board. Rather, demand is concentrated in properties that offer the right combination of price, location, and condition. As we’ve seen throughout the year, what’s happening in one segment of the market isn’t always representative of the next.

Interest Rates Remain a Factor

Mortgage rates continue to play an important role in buyer decisions, particularly in the more financing-dependent parts of the market. When you factor in elevated borrowing costs, monthly carrying costs, and potentially significant renovation expenses, buyers are understandably paying close attention to the numbers.

That’s especially true for properties that need work. Buyers aren’t simply looking at the asking price; they’re considering the total cost of ownership and what it will take to make a property work for them.

Looking Ahead: Will Buyers Return?

With the election behind us, we will be watching to see whether some of the buyers who have been sitting on the sidelines begin to reengage over the coming weeks and months.

While the election’s conclusion may remove a source of uncertainty, the more immediate factor is likely to be the calendar. Thanksgiving is approaching, and historically, activity tends to slow considerably as we move into December.

For sellers, declining inventory means less competition, but it doesn’t automatically translate into more leverage. If a property has been sitting without much interest, now may be the time to revisit pricing rather than waiting until the market gets even quieter.

For buyers, the next several weeks could present some interesting opportunities. Sellers who have been on the market for a while, particularly those who have already made price adjustments, may be more willing to negotiate before the end of the year.

The fall market has shown some improvement, but whether that momentum carries through the holidays remains to be seen. And as always, the broad market numbers only tell part of the story. Building, location, layout, condition, and pricing are still what ultimately determine how an individual property performs.

Whether you’re considering a sale, exploring a purchase, or planning ahead for the spring market, we are always happy to discuss what these trends mean for your particular situation.

Signup for our newsletter